← All public grillings

Grilled10 Rounds

Can loneliness make someone gay, or are they gay?

People don’t become gay from loneliness; you want their feelings not to be real or lasting.

You are using loneliness to make their feelings seem temporary because accepting them would mean admitting you do not understand this person as well as you thought. You still cannot name what you expected to know.

  1. What makes loneliness seem more likely than their being gay?

    I’m uncomfortable accepting that they may be gay.

  2. Are you hoping loneliness would make their feelings temporary?

    Yes; I’d rather their feelings not be real or lasting.

—— Anonymous · Oct 3, 2026

The whole Grilling

Do people become gay because there actually gay or just lonely ?

  1. Round 1

    “Actually gay” versus “just lonely” makes this sound personal, not abstract.

    Whose gayness are you trying to make sense of: yours, someone else's, or people in general?

    • Mine; I’m questioning what I feel.
    • Someone else’s; I’m unsure what their feelings mean.their answer
    • People in general; I’m asking out of curiosity.

  2. Round 2

    You’re treating their feelings as uncertain, not just your interpretation of them.

    What about this person makes you consider loneliness a better explanation than their being gay?

    • They seem to want closeness more than a specific person.
    • Their attraction seems inconsistent to me.
    • I’m uncomfortable accepting that they may be gay.their answer
    • I don’t have a clear reason; I’m guessing.

  3. Round 3

    “Uncomfortable accepting” suggests loneliness would make their feelings easier to dismiss.

    Are you hoping loneliness would make their feelings temporary, so you wouldn’t have to accept that they may be gay?

    • Yes; I’d rather their feelings not be real or lasting.their answer
    • No; I’m uncomfortable, but I’m not hoping they’ll change.
    • Partly; I don’t know what I want their feelings to mean.

  4. Round 4

    You’d rather their feelings weren’t real. That is the issue now.

    What would accepting that they may be gay force you to face about your relationship with them?

    • That our relationship may change.
    • That I may lose the closeness I want from them.
    • That I have to rethink what I believe about them.their answer
    • I don’t know what accepting it would mean for me.

  5. Round 5

    “Rethink what I believe” is still vague; the belief is the point.

    What belief about this person would their being gay make you rethink?

    • That I understood who they are.
    • That they were being honest with me.
    • That we share the same values.
    • I can’t name the belief yet.their answer

  6. Round 6

    You want to dismiss their feelings, but can’t name what accepting them would change.

    If you had to revise what you believe about them, what would unsettle you most?

    • I’d have to admit I didn’t understand them.
    • I’d see them differently from now on.their answer
    • I’d doubt what else I think I know about them.
    • I can’t tell; I just don’t want them to be gay.

  7. Round 7

    You keep naming a changed view, not what would change in it.

    What would you start seeing differently about them if you accepted they’re gay?

    • I’d see a side of them I hadn’t understood.
    • I’d worry their feelings could change our relationship.
    • I’d feel awkward about something I can’t explain.
    • I don’t know; the label itself unsettles me.their answer

  8. Round 8

    The label unsettles you, but you haven’t said what it threatens.

    What does the word “gay” make you fear or assume about this person?

    • That I don’t know them as well as I thought.their answer
    • That they’ll be treated differently by other people.
    • That our relationship will feel different to me.
    • I can’t name an assumption; the word just bothers me.

  9. Round 9

    You fear the label exposes a gap in how well you know them.

    What did you assume you knew about them that their being gay would challenge?

    • I thought I knew who they were attracted to.
    • I thought I understood what they were keeping private.their answer
    • I thought I could predict how they saw themselves.
    • I can’t name what I assumed I knew.

  10. Round 10

    You thought you understood their privacy; that is a claim about access.

    What did you believe about what this person kept private?

    • I thought they weren’t hiding anything important from me.
    • I thought I understood why they kept things private.
    • I assumed their private feelings were much like mine.
    • I expected to understand them, but can’t say what I assumed.their answer

Shared Understanding

People don’t become gay because they’re lonely. You’re using loneliness as an explanation because you want this person’s feelings not to be real or lasting, and their privacy has unsettled your belief that you understood them.

The Question

Do people become gay because they’re actually gay, or because they’re lonely?

What you actually want

You want a reason to treat this person’s feelings as temporary so you don’t have to accept that they may be gay.

What you decided

  • You’re trying to understand someone else’s feelings.
  • You’re uncomfortable accepting that they may be gay.
  • You would rather their feelings not be real or lasting.
  • Accepting they may be gay would make you rethink what you believe about them.
  • You can’t yet name the specific belief you would have to rethink.
  • The label itself unsettles you.
  • You thought you understood what they kept private, though you couldn’t say exactly what you expected to understand.

What you're assuming

  • You assume loneliness could explain or undo this person’s attraction.
  • You assume you can infer what they feel from what they keep private.
  • You have not established what this person’s orientation or feelings actually are.

What you're avoiding

  • You haven’t named what about the label unsettles you.
  • You haven’t explained what you would see differently about this person.
  • You circled around what you expected to know about their private feelings without identifying it.

Next step

In the next few days, write down what this person has actually told you separately from what you’re guessing, and stop using loneliness to explain away their feelings.