Other people’s decisions

Grilled in public, one question at a time. Anonymous, before you ask.

  1. At 31, what happens if I go back to school for two years while working full-time?

    Do not go back to school for two years on this basis.

    1. If your peers kept getting promoted while you studied, would the degree still feel like progress?

      No; promotions are the progress I actually care about.

    2. Would two years of school feel worthwhile if it didn’t improve your promotion prospects?

      No; then it wouldn’t address the progress I care about.

    Anonymous12 RoundsWork

  2. After nearly two years of karate twice a week, I dread going—why do I keep showing up?

    You keep showing up for visible ranks and respect, not enjoyment of training.

    1. If karate offered no ranks or milestones, would you still keep showing up?

      No, the milestones are the reason.

    2. What does other people seeing your karate progress give you that knowing privately wouldn’t?

      It makes me feel respected.

    Anonymous10 RoundsHabits

  3. I left teaching three years ago after six years. I'm eyeing school jobs, but remember how tired I was.

    Do not return to school work now: no evidence the workload will be lighter.

    1. If colleagues backed you up but demands stayed exhausting, would teaching feel worth returning to?

      No; support wouldn’t make that level of exhaustion worth it.

    2. What makes you think a school job could have a substantially lighter workload?

      I haven’t identified a reason; I’m hoping it might be lighter.

    Anonymous10 RoundsWork

  4. After six years of competitive soccer, I’m tired of weeknight practices—slump or time to quit?

    Quit competitive soccer: your dread is about earning your place, not just weeknight practice.

    1. If you could keep the team and routine without competing, would you still want to play?

      No, I mainly want to keep the people and routine.

    2. When you call it a “slump,” what are you hoping is temporary?

      I’m hoping the label means I don’t have to decide yet.

    Anonymous10 Rounds

  5. My boyfriend wants me to move six hours away for his job, but I haven't applied there

    No: don’t move six hours away now or use a job application as proof of commitment.

    1. If distance wouldn’t damage your everyday closeness, would you still want to move?

      No, I’m considering it mainly to protect our closeness.

    2. What makes his relocation the standard for measuring your commitment?

      If I stay, I worry he’ll see it as rejection.

    Anonymous12 RoundsHome

  6. nine years together, nothing's wrong, but i feel nothing when we're apart

    History is not a substitute for desire. Stop pretending.

    1. When did you last want them in a way that surprised you?

      I can't remember

    2. If the wanting is gone, what is the relationship built on now?

      Habit and momentum

    Anonymous11 RoundsLove

  7. three years into a PhD and I can't tell if I'm almost done or just stuck

    You're stuck, not almost done. Talk to your advisor this week.

    1. When did you last tell your advisor what you actually think your contribution is?

      I've never told anyone; I just keep working hoping it becomes clear.

    2. What's stopping you from scheduling that conversation this week?

      There's nothing stopping me; I just haven't done it yet.

    Anonymous11 RoundsSchool

  8. three years in, why do i keep picturing what it would be like to leave

    Stop asking whether leaving is right and start deciding what you actually want from your next three years.

    1. What specifically are you carrying that makes staying feel unbearable?

      That I chose this and now I'm stuck with the choice.

    2. If leaving weren't so complicated, would you have done it already? What's the real barrier?

      I don't know if I'd be right or wrong about this. That's what keeps me here.

    Anonymous10 RoundsWork

  9. Should I just stay single forever?

    No, you shouldn't stay single forever.

    1. What's the actual reason you're thinking this?

      I got hurt by someone.

    2. What makes you think romantic partners are fundamentally different from other trustworthy people?

      You need to be vulnerable with them.

    Anonymous10 RoundsLove

  10. Should I stay in a sexless marriage?

    Stay for now and have the stakes conversation you're avoiding.

    1. What have you been telling yourself to make it bearable?

      I'm being ungrateful for complaining.

    2. What haven't you said in those conversations?

      That I feel replaced, like whatever drew them to me isn't there anymore.

    Anonymous11 RoundsLove