← All public decisions

I left teaching three years ago after six years. I'm eyeing school jobs, but remember how tired I was.

Do not return to school work now: no evidence the workload will be lighter.

You miss the moment students understand, not the exhaustion that came with it. A different team is only a hope, and you have no evidence the workload would be lighter.

  1. If colleagues backed you up but demands stayed exhausting, would teaching feel worth returning to?

    No; support wouldn’t make that level of exhaustion worth it.

  2. What makes you think a school job could have a substantially lighter workload?

    I haven’t identified a reason; I’m hoping it might be lighter.

Anonymous10 RoundsWork

The whole Grilling

I left teaching three years ago after six years. I'm eyeing school jobs, but remember how tired I was.

  1. Round 1

    You remember the exhaustion, but the school setting still has a pull.

    When you picture a school job, what are you most hoping to get back?

    • I miss teaching itself.their answer
    • I miss being part of a school.
    • I want work that feels familiar.
    • I need a job, and schools came to mind.
  2. Round 2

    The pull is teaching itself, not just being back in a school.

    What part of teaching itself do you miss most?

    • Watching students understand something new.their answer
    • Planning lessons and making ideas click.
    • The energy of being with a class.
    • Feeling useful through the work.
  3. Round 3

    You miss the clearest payoff, not the whole working day.

    When you miss students understanding something, are you hoping that payoff would make the exhaustion feel worth it again, or does the exhaustion outweigh it?

    • That payoff made the exhausting days worth it.
    • I miss the payoff, but the exhaustion still outweighs it.their answer
    • I want to teach, but not at that cost.
  4. Round 4

    You miss the payoff, but it still doesn’t outweigh the exhaustion.

    What keeps school jobs in view when you believe the exhaustion outweighs the payoff?

    • I think this time could be different.their answer
    • I hope the payoff will feel stronger now.
    • I don’t see another kind of work I want.
    • I keep returning to what I miss and setting aside the cost.
  5. Round 5

    “Different this time” is carrying the argument, but you haven’t named the difference.

    When you say teaching could be different this time, what difference are you counting on?

    • A lighter workload than before.
    • A different school or team.their answer
    • I’d handle the demands differently now.
    • I’m not sure; I just hope it would feel different.
  6. Round 6

    A different team is a hope, not yet an explanation.

    What do you believe a different school or team would change about the exhaustion you remember?

    • The workload would be more manageable.
    • I’d have better support from colleagues and leaders.their answer
    • The teaching would still be demanding, but feel less draining.
    • I don’t know what would change; I just want this setting to be different.
  7. Round 7

    “Better support” is still broad; its meaning matters to your return.

    What kind of support do you believe would reduce the exhaustion you remember?

    • Leaders who keep the workload manageable.
    • Colleagues who share the pressure and back each other up.their answer
    • More say over how I teach and organize the work.
    • I can’t name it; I just hope support would make it bearable.
  8. Round 8

    You’ve named shared pressure, not a lighter job.

    If the demands stayed as exhausting as before, but colleagues backed you up, would teaching feel worth returning to?

    • Yes; not carrying it alone would change enough.
    • No; support wouldn’t make that level of exhaustion worth it.their answer
    • I can’t tell whether support would change the balance.
  9. Round 9

    Colleague support alone doesn’t change the balance.

    What would need to change for a school job to feel worth considering?

    • The workload would need to be substantially lighter.their answer
    • I’d need more control over the demands.
    • I’d need to believe the exhaustion wouldn’t return.
    • I don’t know; I miss teaching, but the cost still feels too high.
  10. Round 10

    The condition is clear; whether a school job could meet it isn’t.

    When you eye school jobs, what makes you think one could have a substantially lighter workload?

    • I’m considering a different kind of school role.
    • I expect a different school to organize teaching better.
    • I haven’t identified a reason; I’m hoping it might be lighter.their answer
    • I’m not sure the jobs I’m eyeing would meet that condition.

Do not return to a school job now: you miss watching students understand, but you have no reason to expect the workload will be lighter, and colleague support alone would not make the exhaustion worth it.

The Question

Should you return to school work when you miss teaching but remember how tired it made you?

What you actually want

You want to see students understand something new without paying the same exhaustion cost.

What you decided

  • You miss teaching itself, especially watching students understand something new.
  • The exhaustion outweighed the payoff for you.
  • You hoped a different school or team would feel different.
  • You expected colleagues to share the pressure and back you up.
  • Colleague support would not make the same level of exhaustion worth returning to.
  • A school job would need a substantially lighter workload to be worth considering.
  • You have not identified a reason to expect the jobs you are eyeing to be lighter.

What you're assuming

  • A different school or team might provide better colleague support.
  • A school job you are considering might have a substantially lighter workload, though you have no evidence for that yet.

What you're avoiding

  • You have not named a specific role or concrete evidence that its workload would be lighter than your old one.

Next step

  • In the next few days, ask people doing the specific school jobs you are eyeing about their workload, after-hours demands, and colleague support; consider only roles with a demonstrably lighter workload.
All Work decisions
  1. At 31, what happens if I go back to school for two years while working full-time?

    Do not go back to school for two years on this basis.

    1. If your peers kept getting promoted while you studied, would the degree still feel like progress?

      No; promotions are the progress I actually care about.

    2. Would two years of school feel worthwhile if it didn’t improve your promotion prospects?

      No; then it wouldn’t address the progress I care about.

    Anonymous12 RoundsWork

  2. three years in, why do i keep picturing what it would be like to leave

    Stop asking whether leaving is right and start deciding what you actually want from your next three years.

    1. What specifically are you carrying that makes staying feel unbearable?

      That I chose this and now I'm stuck with the choice.

    2. If leaving weren't so complicated, would you have done it already? What's the real barrier?

      I don't know if I'd be right or wrong about this. That's what keeps me here.